In a world drowning in plastic, the word “biodegradable” seems like a beacon of hope. From supermarket shelves to eco-conscious brands, products are proudly labeled as biodegradable or compostable—promising guilt-free consumption and a cleaner planet. But what do these terms really mean? Are biodegradable plastics the solution to the global plastic crisis, or are they just another marketing buzzword with more hype than help?

Let’s understand the science, the reality, and the future of biodegradable plastics.

The Plastic Problem

Plastic pollution is one of the most pressing environmental issues of our time. Each year, the world produces over 430 million tonnes of plastic, with nearly two-thirds used for single-use packaging. Much of this ends up in landfills, oceans, and even inside living organisms—including humans. Traditional plastics, made from petroleum, can take hundreds to thousands of years to degrade, breaking down into microplastics that persist in the environment.

Enter biodegradable plastics, a category of materials designed to break down more quickly and naturally. The idea is appealing: plastic that disappears on its own. But the reality is more complex.

What Are Biodegradable Plastics?

Biodegradable plastics are designed to be broken down by microorganisms—such as bacteria or fungi—into natural elements like water, carbon dioxide, and biomass. But here's the catch: this process depends on very specific environmental conditions.

There are two main categories:

• Bio-based plastics – made from renewable sources like corn starch, sugarcane, or cassava.
• Petrochemical-based biodegradable plastics – made from fossil fuels but with additives that enable microbial degradation.

Bio-based plastics – made from renewable sources like corn starch, sugarcane, or cassava.

Petrochemical-based biodegradable plastics – made from fossil fuels but with additives that enable microbial degradation.

Not all biodegradable plastics are compostable, and not all compostable plastics break down in natural settings like soil or seawater. Many require industrial composting facilities with high heat and controlled humidity—conditions not found in your backyard or local landfill.

Compostable vs. Biodegradable: Not the Same Thing

Let’s clarify two often-confused terms:

• Biodegradable means the material can break down by microbes, eventually disappearing into nature.
• Compostable means the plastic not only biodegrades but does so within a specific timeframe and leaves no toxic residue—typically under industrial composting conditions.

Biodegradable means the material can break down by microbes, eventually disappearing into nature.

Compostable means the plastic not only biodegrades but does so within a specific timeframe and leaves no toxic residue—typically under industrial composting conditions.

So, a biodegradable plastic straw might still sit in a landfill for years if not exposed to the right environment. This has led many scientists and environmental groups to warn against assuming all “green” plastics are truly eco-friendly.

Latest Research: The Good, The Bad, and the Promising

Recent studies offer mixed findings:

• A 2022 UNEP report concluded that many so-called biodegradable plastics do not degrade efficiently in natural environments, especially in the ocean, where lower temperatures and microbial diversity slow decomposition.
• Researchers at the University of Plymouth (UK) buried several biodegradable bags in soil and seawater and found that even after three years, some remained largely intact.
• On a positive note, scientists are developing next-generation bioplastics using bacterial fermentation and enzyme engineering. A 2023 study in Nature Sustainability showed that PHA (polyhydroxyalkanoates)—produced by microbes—can break down in soil and marine environments within months.
• In 2024, researchers from ETH Zurich developed a novel bio-based plastic from whey protein and wood waste that fully degraded in soil within 60 days and showed no toxic leachates, suggesting safer disposal.

A 2022 UNEP report concluded that many so-called biodegradable plastics do not degrade efficiently in natural environments, especially in the ocean, where lower temperatures and microbial diversity slow decomposition.

Researchers at the University of Plymouth (UK) buried several biodegradable bags in soil and seawater and found that even after three years, some remained largely intact.

On a positive note, scientists are developing next-generation bioplastics using bacterial fermentation and enzyme engineering. A 2023 study in Nature Sustainability showed that PHA (polyhydroxyalkanoates)—produced by microbes—can break down in soil and marine environments within months.

In 2024, researchers from ETH Zurich developed a novel bio-based plastic from whey protein and wood waste that fully degraded in soil within 60 days and showed no toxic leachates, suggesting safer disposal.

Real-World Challenges

Biodegradable plastics are not a universal fix. Several practical challenges limit their effectiveness:

• Contamination: If mixed with traditional plastics, biodegradable plastics can contaminate recycling streams.
• Consumer confusion: Misleading labels often lead people to improperly discard items, increasing litter and pollution.
• Limited composting infrastructure: Most cities lack industrial composting facilities capable of processing compostable plastics.
• Cost: Biodegradable plastics are often 2–4 times more expensive to produce than conventional plastics, making widespread adoption difficult.

Contamination: If mixed with traditional plastics, biodegradable plastics can contaminate recycling streams.

Consumer confusion: Misleading labels often lead people to improperly discard items, increasing litter and pollution.

Limited composting infrastructure: Most cities lack industrial composting facilities capable of processing compostable plastics.

Cost: Biodegradable plastics are often 2–4 times more expensive to produce than conventional plastics, making widespread adoption difficult.

So… Hype or Hope?

Biodegradable plastics do offer hope, especially when used in closed-loop systems like food service at festivals, stadiums, or airlines—where waste can be properly collected and composted. But they are not a silver bullet.

As long as they are treated as a license for overconsumption, their environmental impact remains questionable. Experts agree that biodegradable plastics should be one part of a larger shift toward:

• Reducing single-use items
• Improving global recycling systems
• Supporting reuse models
• Investing in circular economy strategies

Reducing single-use items

Improving global recycling systems

Supporting reuse models

Investing in circular economy strategies

What Can You Do?

• Read beyond the label: Look for third-party certifications like TÜV OK Compost, BPI Certified, or ASTM D6400.
• Reduce and reuse before reaching for biodegradable alternatives.
• Compost responsibly: Industrial composting centers are often needed—don’t throw compostable plastics in your garden pile or recycling bin.
• Support innovation: Encourage local governments and businesses to invest in sustainable materials and better waste infrastructure.

Read beyond the label: Look for third-party certifications like TÜV OK Compost, BPI Certified, or ASTM D6400.

Reduce and reuse before reaching for biodegradable alternatives.

Compost responsibly: Industrial composting centers are often needed—don’t throw compostable plastics in your garden pile or recycling bin.

Support innovation: Encourage local governments and businesses to invest in sustainable materials and better waste infrastructure.

Final Thoughts

Biodegradable plastics carry promise, but they’re not a magic wand. In the rush to replace traditional plastics, we must avoid falling for greenwashed solutions. The real path to sustainability lies in rethinking our relationship with materials, not just replacing one with another.

As science improves, truly biodegradable plastics may play a key role in a cleaner future—but only if we pair them with clear policies, smart design, and collective responsibility.

Thanks for reading The Research Code’s Newsletter! This post is public so feel free to share it.

Share